National Soul-Searching: Lawsuit Over 9-Year-Old Handcuffed at School Sparks Reckoning on School Policing

The handcuffing of a 9-year-old boy by a police officer at a Florida school has captured nationwide attention and prompted a nuanced discussion about the role of law enforcement within educational environments.

The unfolding of these events on school grounds has led to considerable concerns about the officer’s response. As a reaction to the disturbing occurrence, the boy’s parents have initiated a lawsuit against the city and the school resource officers involved, questioning whether it is appropriate for law enforcement to take significant actions in school settings.

Exploring the Incident

The sequence of events, captured on an officer’s body camera and reported on video by WSVN 7News in Miami, went as follows:

The school staff attempted to calm a student who was exhibiting some problematic behavior, cursing and throwing items around the mailroom. They tried to manage the situation using blocking pads designed for such scenarios; however, the situation escalated to the point where the officers felt the need to handcuff the 9-year-old boy in an attempt to calm him down.

One of the officers can be heard saying, “Stand up for me, bud. Chill, chill. Stop it.” The officers and school staff continued their attempts to pacify the child, with one staff member saying, “If you can relax, we’ll take the cuffs off. Thank you for relaxing. Getting better.”

However, the lawsuit filed by the student’s family points out that their child has known behavioral issues, and according to a formal action plan already in place, when confronted with his aggressions, staff should “not engage with any conversation other than having him complete the task… and to otherwise limit the level of attention directed to him.”

After being handcuffed, the dialogue continued, with the boy expressing his desire to leave and the school staff member responding, “You’re not going to go home. So, you want to go to jail?” The boy was handcuffed for around 13 minutes before being released.

The lawsuit, which names the city and the officers involved but not the school district itself, has incited a heated discussion over law enforcement actions in school environments.

Broader Implications

The boy’s family has filed a lawsuit against the police department. They argue that the officer’s actions were excessive and inappropriate for dealing with a child, especially in a school setting, regardless of whether they have behavioral challenges. The family’s attorney has stated that the incident caused the boy significant trauma.

The case has raised important questions about the role of police in schools. Advocates for police-free schools argue that this incident is a clear example of why law enforcement should not be present in educational environments.

They believe that situations like these can be handled more effectively by trained educators and mental health professionals.

On the other hand, supporters of police in schools contend that officers are necessary to maintain safety and order.

They argue that law enforcement officers are equipped to handle situations that educators may not be prepared for. They believe that incidents like these, while regrettable, are exceptions and not the norm.

A Relevant Precedent: The 2019 Orlando Case

In line with the recent incident, a previous case from 2019 in Orlando, Florida, offers a relevant precedent. A 6-year-old girl was arrested and handcuffed by a school resource officer.

The event caused an outcry across the nation, leading to the termination of the officer involved and a reevaluation of the law regarding police interaction with minors in the state.

Changes to the Law Post-2019 Incident

The 2019 incident led to significant changes in the Florida State law regarding the arrest and handcuffing of minors.

The state enacted legislation that limits the ability of law enforcement officers to arrest children under certain ages without a warrant for non-serious offenses.

Furthermore, the legislation also called for additional training for school resource officers, focusing on de-escalation techniques and how to interact with minors effectively and appropriately.

Looking Ahead

As the lawsuit progresses, the incident will undoubtedly continue to stir debate about police presence in schools. It will also likely prompt a reevaluation of the policies that guide officers’ actions in these settings.

Regardless of the outcome, the incident serves as a stark reminder of the delicate balance between maintaining order and protecting the physical and emotional well-being of students.


This article was produced by TPR Teaching.

Caitriona Maria is an education writer and founder of TPR Teaching, crafting inspiring pieces that promote the importance of developing new skills. For 7 years, she has been committed to providing students with the best learning opportunities possible, both domestically and abroad. Dedicated to unlocking students' potential, Caitriona has taught English in several countries and continues to explore new cultures through her travels.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments